This is the second time a show, and the first time for a Best Of show, has had both a guest host and a guest scorekeeper and the first time.

The Not My Job guest segment with John Leguizamo was from his second appearance on the show that aired on 2024-09-07.

The Panel Question segment most likely came from the 2025-01-25 show with Chioke I'Anson as the guest scorekeeper.

Negin Farsad was the guest host for the 2023-08-26 show with Mark Ronson as the Not My Job guest.

Joshua Johnson was the guest scorekeeper for the 2024-11-09 show with Tara Dower as the Not My Job guest.

Peter Grosz was the guest host for the 2023-02-09 show with Billy Porter as the Not My Job guest.

During the Not My Job segment with Eric Idle on the discussion about the show being aired on the BBC, there was a Windows notification sound that played. That portion of the interview was not included in the original airing of the Not My Job segment from the show that aired on 2024-10-12.

Tim Meadows was the guest scorekeeper for the 2024-11-23 show with Bridget Everett and Jeff Hiller as the Not My Job guests.

Chioke I'Anson was the guest scorekeeper for the 2025-02-01 show with Amber Maykut as the Not My Job guest and for the 2025-02-15 show with Mike Bishop and Mike Derks of GWAR as the Not My Job guests.

Chioke I'Anson was the guest scorekeeper for the 2025-01-25 show with mxmtoon as the Not My Job guest.

Both the Bluff the Listener and the Not My Job segment with Dylan Thuras and Louise Story of Atlas Obscura were from a show that was taped at the Merrill Auditorium in Portland, Maine on 2025-06-27. The segments have never been aired until this Best Of show.

Chioke I'Anson was the guest scorekeeper for the show that aired on 2025-01-18 with Rose Matafeo as the Not My Job guest.

Alzo Slade was the guest scorekeeper for the 2025-05-10 show with Nathan Lane as the Not My Job guest.

The 2025-02-08 show with Vanessa Bayer as the Not My Job guest was the first show with both a guest host, Tom Papa, and a guest scorekeeper, Chioke I'Anson.

Karen Chee was the guest host for the 2025-04-26 show with Brian Tyree Henry as the Not My Job guest.

Tom Papa was the guest host for the "Medical Bill" Panelist Questions segment that was not included in the show that aired on 2025-08-09.

The Bluff the Listener segment was from the show that aired on 2025-05-24.

Che "Rhymefest" Smith was the guest scorekeeper for the 2025-09-13 show with Bob Costas as the Not My Job guest.

Both the Bluff the Listener segment and the Not My Job segment with Carissa Moore were from the second show recorded on 2025-10-10 in Honolulu, Hawaii. Since the Bluff the Listener segment is unique to this Best Of show, both the chosen panelist and the panelist with the correct story have been entered.

For Carissa Moore's second Not My Job question, she liked "A" and she also liked how Peter Sagal said "leather cardigan" for "B". Carissa asked Peter if both "A" and "B" are incorrect, leaving "C" to be the correct answer. Peter confirmed that "C" was the correct answer and that is what Carissa chose for her answer, which she got credit.

For the Panel Questions segment, the NPR.org transcripts lists the second panelist as Emmy Blotnick, even though the panelist sounds more like Amy Dickinson. Amy Dickinson, Alonzo Bodden and Shane O'Neill were the panelists for the 2025-09-06 show. Thus, I have included Amy into the list of panelists. The panel question for Alex Edelman was from the 2025-10-25 show with Hari Kondabolu and Faith Salie on the panel.